The Best Glock 23 Holsters – Recommendations from the Experts

The Glock 23 is a great carry gun and it deserves a good holster. Whether you’re replacing an old holster you have or buying a new holster for your Glock 23 that you just bought, we’ve compiled a list of the best holsters (IWB included) for your 23.

Keep reading to find out which holsters our experts picked for the Glock 23.

1. BlackHawk Serpa Sportster Paddle Holster

A name we all know. BlackHawk has been making holsters (and a bunch of other stuff) for a long time, and they are trusted to be durable, reliable, and have a low price point.

There are a couple of minor setbacks, though. This holster absolutely performs. It will hold your weapon in place until needed, and the tension is adjustable. The hard polymer is notorious for scratching pretty weapons, and this is very much a paddle holster, not always suitable for concealed carry. It’s a solid holster for an everyday carry around the farm, with that gun that you don’t mind abusing from time to time.

It comes at a pretty good price too.

2. The Defender Leather IWB Holster for Glock 23

Leather is definitely the way to go if you want a solid holster with good grip, and this one doesn’t disappoint. It’s designed in a generic sense, to fit a range of handguns, and it makes a perfect home for your Glock 23.

Once broken in, this holster has good retention, is comfortable to wear, and won’t scratch up the slide locking lever on your Glock.

Leather is very much a living material, though, and will tend to stretch slightly over time, even after the break-in period. It could loosen up with time. You will also want to take care of it as you would all leather products. A good oiling once in a while never hurts. No cant adjustment on this one. So if that’s a deal-breaker, this might not be the Glock 23 holster for you.

Here’s a link to the Defender holster for Glock 23 on Amazon (best price).

3. Relentless Tactical – The Ultimate Leather Gun Holster

Another leather holster, with all of the same leather issues above. Designed to be worn on a belt, it contains two different slots on the right side to adjust the cant of your Glock 23.

American made, handmade, and high quality leather make this a comfortable home for your pistol, especially for concealed carry. It does have a reputation for being a little too soft, so if you wear your belt tight, you may want to keep the belt between yourself and the holster instead of over it.

Overall, a solid design, and a very nice holster. The kind that you show off to your friends.

4. ComfortTac Belly Band Holster

Belly-band holsters can seem a bit odd at first, but when it comes to comfort and concealment of your Glock 23, accept no substitute. This one is no different.

The retaining strap for the firearm is absolutely essential, on belly-band style holsters more than any other. As you move, so does the holster, it bends, squeezes, and if not properly secured, your Glock 23 will jump right out of its pocket. The same is true of the “mag pouch” on the band. There’s no way to seal it, so it makes a better “wallet” pouch when you are out running, or a place to drop your phone.

Draw time is going to be slower with these. As said, the band tends to move, so your Glock won’t stay exactly where you left it through the course of the day. The retaining strap doesn’t break away easily on its own, which means drawing your weapon is a two-step procedure. But if comfort is the most important thing, belly band is the obvious choice.

5. Fierce Defender IWB Holster

Looking for the perfect blend of comfort, concealment, and retention? Look no further. This holster does it all, and is fitted perfectly for your Glock. Kydex to hold your weapon, and leather against your skin or undershirt. This increases weapon retention while cutting down on rashes and cuts that can result from other Kydex holsters.

Well made, and for the price, you can’t beat this combination of materials. This holster is adjustable and sturdy. It is an absolute treasure in the holster world, if you don’t mind the extra bulk.

Which Holster is Right for Your Glock 23?

Well, that depends. You have to have a compromise between comfort, quality and dependability. Not knowing whether or not your gun is going to get stuck in your holster in an emergency is a scary thing. You need to take your time, read reviews and pick a high-quality holster that’s going to fit your Glock 23 right and last you a long time.

We think that we’ve given you some very good options for your Glock 23 above, but we’re always wanting to hear from our readers. Give us a shout if you’ve got a holster that you like better for your Glock 23 or if you have any questions.

Also, if you’re interested in getting a laser sight for your Glock, we’ve got a great guide to the best lasers for Glock as well.